Lee sounds warning on Iskandar Malaysia, but the same occurred in Singapore

CapitaLand's investment in Puteri Harbour, Ascott Somerset Puteri Harbour.
CapitaLand’s investment in Puteri Harbour, Ascott Somerset Puteri Harbour which is still under construction. Photo: Khalil Adis.

When the man speaks, the entire nation listens.

Although retired from politics, former Prime Minister Lee Kuan Yew still wields considerable influence and is regarded as one of Asia’s most critical voices, especially when it comes to Malaysia.

Therefore, when Lee Kuan Yew recently spoke about the risks involved when investing in Iskandar Malaysia in his latest book, ‘One Man’s View of the World’ it caught the attention of both Singaporeans as well as across the causeway.

“This is an economic field of co-operation in which, you must remember, we are putting investments on Malaysian soil. And at the stroke of a pen they can take it over,” Lee was reported as saying.

Iskandar Malaysia was first mooted in 2006 by former Malaysian Prime Minister Abdullah Badawi.

It has now succeeded beyond its wildest dreams with record investments now valued at RM116 billion, according to the latest figure by Iskandar Regional Development Authority (IRDA).

First met with sceptisms and tepid response from Singapore, the city-state has over the years warmed up to Iskandar Malaysia owing to the excellent bilateral ties between the Lee Hsien Loong and Najib administrations.

Space constrains in Singapore versus the abundance of land, natural resources and access to cheap labour has made Iskandar Malaysia a sort of hinterland for land scarce Singapore.

The Republic is now the largest investor in the special economic zone led by Temasek Holdings and CapitaLand.

Figures from IRDA cites Singapore investments at RM6.05 billion followed by Spain, Japan, Netherlands and United Arab Emirates at RM4.18 billion, RM3.42 billion, RM2.80 billion and RM1.89 billion respectively.

Singapore cooling measures were implemented overnight

The aim of this article is to lay down the facts and present both sides of the story so that investors can make a more informed decision.

While Lee is right in raising his concerns about Iskandar Malaysia, the same can be said about policy changes in Singapore’s property sector.

In fact, the seventh property cooling measures that was announced on 11 January 2013 had affected investors overnight, leading investors to rush to sign documents to beat the clock.

Some of these measure that took effect on 12 January included new Additional Buyers’ Stamp Duty rates for Singapore citizens, permanent residents and foreigners buying their second properties at 7 per cent, 10 per cent and 15 per cent respectively.

Another one was the minimum cash down payment for individuals applying for a second or subsequent housing loan.

It was raised from 10 per cent to 25 per cent overnight.

The Loan-to-Value (LTV) ratio was also decreased for those with one or more outstanding loan – investors had to come up with 50 per cent cash upfront.

While the state of Johor had announced it was reviewing property tax on foreign owned properties, it will only be announced and implemented towards the end of the year giving investors sufficient time to react.

Puteri Harbour Family Theme Park officially opens

Themed Attractions and Resorts managing director and CEO Tunku Dato’ Ahmad Burhanuddin at the opening ceremony

Themed Attractions and Resorts managing director and CEO Tunku Dato’ Ahmad Burhanuddin at the opening ceremony. Photo: Darren Ong.

Following hot on the heels of LEGOLAND MALAYSIA’s opening in September this year, Iskandar Malaysia welcomed its second tourism attraction yesterday.

Costing RM110 million (US$36 million), Themed Attractions Malaysia said Puteri Harbour Family Theme park had already attracted some 35,000 visitors, including those from Singapore and overseas.

“The opening the Puteri Harbour Family Theme Park is an achievement as we have successfully clinched internationally renowned brands and cartoon characters that are popular and recognised in the whole world. We have also not forgotten Lat’s Place which represents our local brand to place it in the same standing as these international brands,” said Themed Attractions and Resorts managing director and CEO Tunku Dato’ Ahmad Burhanuddin referring to Hello Kitty, Bob the Builder, Barney, Angelina Ballerina, Pingu and Thomas and Friends.

“I am confident and I believe our goals to make Iskandar Malaysia a competitive region and a high income economy by 2020 will be achieved. The rapid developments that we see today are proof that the economic transformation programmes (ETP) that have been planned by the Malaysian government is coming to fruition. In my opinion, these projects must continue to ensure our aspirations are achieved,” said Johor Menteri Besar Datuk Abdul Ghani Othman, representing Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak.

Johor Menteri Besar Datuk Abdul Ghani Othman showing Lego model of the High Court.

Johor Menteri Besar Datuk Abdul Ghani Othman showing Lego model of the High Court.

The theme park, located in the narrowest Straits of Johor to Singapore, is part of the Malaysian government’s broader plan to encourage investments within Iskandar Malaysia and to enjoy the economic spillover from Singapore.

More things to do in Iskandar

Puteri Harbour Family Them Park was launched with a big bang.

Puteri Harbour Family Them Park was launched with a big bang. Photo: Darren Ong.

For decades, the Malaysian state of Johor had been bypassed by Singaporeans and expatriates from Singapore for the more established city of Kuala Lumpur, where many perceive it to be the hub of commerce and entertainment.

By 2013, Puteri Harbour is set to be buzzing even more with the opening of Trader’s Hotel and CapitaLand’s Puteri Harbour Ascott Somerset.

Already, investors have snapped up condos within the vicinity such as Imperia which was priced at around RM650 per sq ft and is now fully sold.

More property launches are expected ahead with the commencement of ferry services to and from Singapore at the Puteri Harbour CIQ Facility.

Ferry services are expected to commence by November next year.

Khalil Adis with celebrated cartoonist, Datuk Lat. Photo: Darren Ong.

Khalil Adis with celebrated cartoonist, Datuk Lat. Photo: Darren Ong.

“Personally I would really like to go at least once just to check it out,” said Adlina Majid, a teacher and a self-confessed Hello Kitty fan, whose parents frequent Johor Bahru for grocery shopping.

Datuk Ismail Ibrahim, chief executive of Iskandar Regional Development Authority (IRDA), said  a total of 20,000 employment opportunities have been created to date.

“The spillover effect to tourism, business and others will also be significant and I urge investors to see this potential and grab the opportunity now,” said Ibrahim.

In July, Ibrahim revealed that Iskandar Malaysia has secured RM10.67 billion (US$3.4 billion) worth of a new committed investment.

The property sector alone has recorded RM29.80 billion (US$9.5 billion) worth of investments.

Iskandar Malaysia is expected to surpass the RM100 billion (US$37.73 billion) dollar mark by 2013.